Saturday, 27 August 2022

Tewkesbury 1471 and the Men of Piggy Longton



This is a post that mixes a boardgame with a figures narrative background.


For those who don’t know, I have been running a number of linked figure battles in a fictional setting called Piggy Longton. Part of the ‘imaginations’ narrative has spilled onto the national stage, as King Henry, who visited Piggy Longton, moved back down to London and immediately became embroiled with the Battle of Barnet, which the Lancastrians lost and Henry found himself a prisoner in the Tower of London.


While the smaller actions at the hamlet are played out with my figure collection, I am using my Men of Iron boardgame system from GMT to do the set piece big battles. We have already done Barnet and now the narrative at the national level is pushing us towards Tewkesbury.


Queen Margaret (Lancastrian) has gathered an army to march on London, to defeat Edward and release King Henry from captivity. The two armies clash at Tewkesbury, a critical battle that will likely decide the issue of royal dynasty and of importance to me …. who will be granted control of Lord Darcy’s estates (Piggy Longton). 


Both Edward and Margaret had sent out a call to arms to their respective followers to give support and so this spills into our Piggy Longton world as we are about to witness our key land owners being drawn into the national conflict.


With Queen Margaret’s ‘invitation’ to Lord Darcy to bring his forces and Edward’s  expectation for Lord Trebian to do the same, we will see our Piggy Longton characters brought into the boardgame.


Please use the ‘read more’ tab for the rest of this post.







Lord Darcy will provide retinue billmen plus the renown bowmen of Piggy Longton to the Lancastrian cause. Lord Trebian will provide two contingents of bill to Edward’s Yorkist army.


This creates four extra units that will be added to the boardgame scenario. They will be randomly allocated to one of the formations for their respective sides and then the flight level of the said formations will be increased by 1 point and each army flight level increased by 1. 


If any of these four additional counters are lost in the game, a D6 will be rolled per loss and on a score of ‘1’ their respective Lord (either Darcy or Trebian) will be killed on the field of battle!


For every melee attack and every 2 missile attacks that Darcy / Trebian troops make, they will earn their lord a glory point. At the end of play, if Edward (Yorkist) wins the battle, King Henry will be killed and Edward will become king and may choose to reward Trebian with Darcy’s lands - that will be sorted on a die roll and the player with the most glory points will favourably modify that die roll …. There is much to fight for!





Above - Darcy contingents are each identified by the number 7, Trebian’s by the numbers 1 and 2.


The dice are rolled and it transpires that Darcy takes position on the Lancastrian left with Devon, while Trebian stands with Hastings on the Yorkist right ….. yes, fate has put these two locally opposed neighbours facing each other - this might get personal!


On to Battle!

There are three elements in this battle that get special coverage; 1) The Yorkist have hidden a small cavalry unit in a wooded area out on their far left - there are ambush rules that cover their arrival into the game. 2) Somerset (Lancastrian) launched a determined attack at the Yorkist left flank - to help represent this, Somerset gets a ‘momentum’ advantage to help keep up his sustained attack. 3) the terrain between the armies had extensive hedgerow and undergrowth that disrupted forces moving through them, but provided good defensive cover.


One final thing - the scenario puts a time restriction / penalty on the Yorkist player, intended to ensure that the historical attacker (Yorkists) gets a move on and engages the enemy. Each time the Lancastrians Pass on their first activation, that timer ticks away.





Above - starting positions. Lancastrians are the red counters. Edward is in the centre of the Yorkist line.





Above - difficult terrain to move through, but it does give defensive cover.


The initial thought for the Lancastrian player is to sit in their hands. The timed aspect of the game will compel the Yorkists to have to attack them and make them move though the difficult and disruptive terrain that lines the lateral lane.


One of the genuine quirks of todays set-up is that the dice have placed Darcy on the far Lancastrian left and Trebian on the far Yorkist right. Further dice rolls for positioning amazingly have them directly facing each other!


Edward orders his army forwards. He uses the ‘Army Command’, so that everything can advance at once, rather than the usual ‘hope and pray’ activation and momentum system for dealing with individual formations.





Above - On the Yorkist right, Trebian’s forces move out to circumvent the difficult terrain and bring themselves to threaten the Lancastrian left. Suddenly things are now moving too quickly for the Lancastrians to simply ‘pass’ each phase to move the timer down. 





Above - Devon reacts by ordering Darcy to move out and extend the left wing, but their archery is poor and they do nothing to disrupt Trebian’s manoeuvring and his billmen crash into the Lancastrians. The archers of Piggy Longton are sent fleeing towards their battle’s standard. What a great opening!


In that top attack, The Men of Piggy Longton are sent
reeling back to Devon’s standard - a rallying point.



Somerset on the Lancastrian right attacks Gloucester, hoping to get a flanking advantage, but despite heavily disordering Gloucester, the attack fizzles out too early. Worse, the cavalry ambush that Gloucester had hidden amongst some woods comes into play and it hits Somerset’s archers in the rear. 


Ambushing cavalry gets behind Somerset’s archers.



Gloucester goes onto the counter-attack and in short order, Somerset is killed and his forces crushed, they flee the battlefield, but the charismatic and disciplined Gloucester holds his battle together and they don’t pursue. 



This total collapse of the Lancastrian right looks even more perilous when their left is assaulted by Hastings and they lose their dismounted Men-at-Arms unit and Devon is killed. For a moment the writing is on the wall, both Lancastrian flanks are compromised, should they escape now, while they can?


Hastings is pushed back



But then a pivotal moment. The Lancastrian left forcibly counter-attack and push Hastings all the way back to his standard. This briefly exposes Edward who is in the Yorkist centre, to both frontal and flank pressure.


It really is a case of whoever can activate first and the most often will seize the moment. The Lancastrians win a number of successive activations, while the Yorkists don’t, so they are limited to just trying to manoeuvre Edward, to keep his flanks secure. This keeps Hastings frustratingly inactive, standing on the sideline, unable to interfere.





Above - The Lancastrian centre (under Wenlock) and the left wing, pile the pressure on to Edward’s battle, which eventually breaks and flees. Wenlock is killed in the action, but Edward survives and safely leaves the battlefield.


The game has a Flight Track, where casualties are recorded. Once the level of casualties reaches the figure set by the scenario, that side loses. To make this more dynamic, whenever flight is tested a D10 is added to current casualty level, so there is game tension in these rolls once you get within 10 points of army collapse …. you may or may not collapse!


Although the situation at the moment on the map looks to decidedly favour the Lancastrians, the truth is that both armies have taken heavy casualties and both are within the D10 range of losing the game when testing, so it is of some satisfaction that when the test comes, it is the Yorkists who roll high enough to hit their break level and they simply lose the battle - this is a good reflection of what the tactical situation looks like on the map and feels right.


Conclusion.

Well there was a bit of a surprise there. Partway through the game, with the Lancastrian right fleeing and their left under great pressure, with Devon killed, it looked a certainty that we were going to get a Yorkist early win, but the activation / momentum system of this game leaves plenty of room for surprise and opportunities to be both gained and lost and here, the Lancastrians managed to turn things around, helped by the inactivity of Hastings.


Well what does this mean for our imaginations campaign at Piggy Longton and for the national picture? 


As to the latter, rather than the historical outcome that saw Edward the victor, the detained King Henry killed and then Edward taking the crown - instead, we can assume that Margaret’s Army will march onto London and free Henry and that Edward will continue to be at large, keeping Yorkist ambitions as a real threat …. future battles in 1472 perhaps!


As to Piggy Longton, the restoration of Henry means that Darcy does not need to worry about the loss of his estates ….. though who knows, perhaps Trebian (of West Rottingham) will! During the battle, Darcy gained the most glory points, so he will still likely have some sway with the decisions that Henry makes.


As for losses, the men of Piggy Longton (archers) did recover their nerve and return to battle, but Trebian lost one of his bill units, so no doubt in the next local engagement at Piggy Longton, Trebian will struggle to put out retinue billmen and will be relying on his levy a little more. 


This game was notable by the significant number of leaders lost, but what of Darcy and Trebian? The loss of his bill unit caused Trebian to test for his own death as explained earlier - he needs to avoid a roll of ‘1’. I held my breath and rolled the dice, losing Trebian after all that I have invested in him would seem a shame …… a ‘2’ is rolled, phew!


So with both Trebian and Darcy returning to their estates and the festering relationship between Yorkist and Lancastrian still very much alive, it looks like there will be more Piggy Longton actions on the figure table in the future, 


As an aside, looking at the game we have just played, that initial manoeuvre, where Trebian moves the Yorkist flank out to strike at Devon, looks like it has the potential to create a small Tewkesbury side action scenario to put up on the figures table at some future point, just for the spectacle of it.


I hope the reader has enjoyed the melding of a boardgame scenario being inter-twined with what has been going on in my imaginations campaign and the figures table. I think each gives the other greater narrative significance and strength.


Resource Section.


For those who have never heard of the Piggy Longton Chronicles, here are two links to some earlier engagements - LINK


The Battle of Longton Fields;

http://battlefieldswarriors.blogspot.com/2022/01/the-battle-of-longton-fields-1471-piggy.html


Stand firm and save the treasury:

http://battlefieldswarriors.blogspot.com/2020/11/1471-stand-firm-save-treasury.html


My sister webspace COMMANDERS is being re-configured to showcase various figure and boardgame systems that I am enjoying and give a flavour of where current ongoing projects are up to. Link.


https://commanders.simdif.com


35 comments:

  1. Brilliant idea mixing board and miniature games. It’s added a whole new slant to the piggy longton escapades too. What happens now board game wise if you’ve broken the historical timeline though?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well that is the interesting consequence of my 1471 history going right off the rails - my first thoughts are to use any of the comparable maps in my collection, while using the counters from Men-of-Iron and make up some scenario’s.

    Less work would be to (for example) take the order of battle (or equivalent) from 2nd St. Albans, but play the game out, say, on the Edgehill map that I have from my Musket and Pike game etc.

    Whatever happens, at some point in 1472, I am going to want there to be a major clash.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great stuff as ever Norm, thanks. I don't think I'd ever venture in minatures myself, but I really enjoy reading about how you mix the two together. Not for the first time your writing makes me wonder if I should broaden my wargaming perspectives...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Gareth, thank you. I enjoy a foot in both camps ..... but it does double the things that I want to do :-)

      Delete
  4. Not a board game player as you know Norm, but that was a really interesting read. To see how the outcomes affect Piggy Longton was really clever use of the board games outcomes. I'm glad the main protagonists survived to fight on.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi David, great fun for me as Piggy Longton is becoming a real place and I am starting to like both Darcy and Trebian and all of their hangers-on. :-)

    Everything I do with them is above board and subject to dice and risk, so it is only a matter of time before one of them falls. Let us hope it is not too soon!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks Phil, looks like Piggy Longton has more to give :-)

    ReplyDelete
  7. I always knew the Piggy Longton idea was a great one, Norm, and the clever way you have linked it the national campaigns, via your board gaming, is a master stroke! Even if/when you have exhausted the WotR potential, you can jump forward a few generations and have the same families involved in Elizabethen tussles and/or the ECW....the potential is almost endless!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Keith, there is a good meld going on between the figures and the boardgame. For Piggy Longton, I see the potential for stepping back to 1066, forwards to ECW and even forwards to WWII for a few ‘Sealion’ type incidents.

      Delete
  8. Great report Norm, very enjoyable! It is great to have the rivalry between the Lancastrians and the Yorkists played out on a smaller scale between Darcy and Trebian. Hopefully they both have sons available if they fall in battle!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Ben, yes the War of the Roses period gives good opportunity for waring neighbours. Recently, Trebian’s son has been introduced and took his first command in battle ….. I must do the same for Darcy as soon as possible, because their luck can’t hold forever :-)

      Delete
  9. Excellent report, first I haven’t fought the Tewkesbury scenario yet and I certainly wasn’t expecting the turnaround in your game. The merging of your figure campaign with board game is very well done and is something I shall take note of as I am contemplating doing something similar but for the ECW.
    I’m pleased the two principle characters survived and I’m looking forward to their next meeting.
    As has already been mentioned I’m extremely interested in how you take this forward, now the historical time line has been changed.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hi, thanks, yes the possibilities of national battles going into 1472 has opened this up somewhat (that did surprise me).

    GMT have just reprinted their Musket & Pike boardgame as a stand alone and also they have done a duel pack with Sweden stands alone and the advantage of that pack is that they throw in two bonus ECW scenarios. I did own it once before and found the rules a little heavy, however, I have re-bought into it and am hopeful that this time around I can invest a little more time in it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Norm, not certain why my comment went anonymous! I’ve just received my double pack but I also forgot I’d ordered the Civil War box as well and forgot to cancel so I will be putting that up for sale shortly

      Delete
    2. Hi Graham, were you using aniPad with cross tracking switched off?

      That double pack is amazing value, though I find it odd that they released the original stand alone games without adding the bonus scenarios - I suppose that would create too much competition between the two titles. Annoying for you though that you now have the hassle of selling.

      Delete
  11. A great idea to mix both formats. With the board game all the work gas already been done, so why not use it?

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi Ray, indeed, plus I like to return to these things fairly often before the rules slip too much from memory and I end up doing a total re-learn.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Amazing conclusion... though really "to be continued" is the message of the day! For which, count me as mighty relieved. I was dreading a decisive Yorkist win, which, as your early narrative unfolded, looked exceedingly likely. Thankfully both Darcy and Trebian live on, though the latter will certainly have his wings clipped for a while.
    Love the way you've blended miniature scenarios with our hex and counter world.

    Can't help wondering if a certain character in a famous Austen novel might not be a descendant in the Darcy line!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Mike agree with all of that. Even with my inclinations, I played honestly to the dice rolls and so was totally hostage to Lady Luck - which just happened to (I think) give us the best conclusion :-)

      Austen’s Darcy ….. We might entertain the possibility, as he had held a military rank (so was militaristic in nature) and his wealth was based upon amassed wealth from several generations. I fancy that his immediate ancestry to the area of Pemberley in Derbyshire warrants further exploration amongst the parish records of both Piggy Longton and Pemberley.

      Delete
    2. Yes, we know each other to well, to think either of us could fudge inconvenient die rolls in solo play!

      Delete
  14. Well thank goodness Darcy and Trebian lived through the battle after all that narrative investment. It’s too soon for one to perish anyway: it’ll be more satisfying later on.
    😀
    Now you’re solidly in the realm of historical fiction. An opportunity to rewrite the WoTR.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Stew, yes, we can breathe a collective sigh of relief. I think any rewrite of the historical direction would still have to have a ‘Bosworth’ in it …… somewhere :-)

      Delete
  15. A brilliant idea of how to meld the two together there Norm:)! I'm certainly looking forward to more Piggy Lonton action as well as them featuring on the bigger stages at some future point.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thanks Steve - more to come and I certainly could’t have said that a week ago.

    ReplyDelete
  17. As said above it's a wonderful mix of historical fact and fiction and was a great read Norm.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hi Lee, glad you liked. I am enjoying seeing the build up of your napoleonic Epic - very nice.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Great stuff! I don't own any War of Roses boardgames or figs but always enjoy reading others ventures in it. Bit sad though because I do favor the Yorkists. Glad both Darcy and Trebian survived though so the feud continues.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Hi, thanks, who knows what the fullness of 1472 might bring, but the Yorkists will certainly be putting the Lancastrians to test.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Great fun write up! I'm looking forward to 1472!
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
  22. Thanks Iain, I played Tewkesbury sooner rather than later based upon your previous encouragement of doing that. 1472 gives us a lot if scope to play with from an imaginations point of view.

    ReplyDelete
  23. That was amazing. What a good idea

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thank you, I like the way these things give you a blank canvas and you can have a variety of permutations fall from them.

    ReplyDelete
  25. I just love these fanta-historic narrations Norm! Keep ‘em coming!

    ReplyDelete
  26. Hi Mike, 1471, now going into 1472 just seems to be the gift that keeps on giving, more to come for sure :-)

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for taking the time to comment